Being a Good… Libertarian

This week, we’re gonna take a brief look at Libertarianism. We won’t spend as much time as previous weeks since less than 1% of registered voters identify as Libertarians (though, presumably, many more would identify if they better understood the ideology). Also, like we did with Democrats and Republicans, we’re going to focus on the Libertarian Party.

Though it holds no seats in Congress or as governor, the Libertarian Party is the third largest political group in America. It synthesized in its present form in response to the perceived shortcomings of Republican candidate Richard Nixon and is today known for promoting civil liberties, non-interventionism, and laissez-faire capitalism.

While Libertarians can often be found in the urban south, the ideology is significantly more geographically diverse than the two other major parties. People are drawn toward this third option for a variety of reasons. I myself have flirted with its merits in a recent blog post and have discussed the array of possibilities for holding Libertarian convictions.

Social Issues

Socially, Libertarians are generally seen as more liberal. They advocate for ending the war on drugs and capital punishment and support same-sex marriage. Conversely, they often promote gun ownership rights.

The common thread for their stance on social issues is their belief that individuals should be able to make their own decisions as long as they do not harm others. For Libertarians, government should not be in the business of legislating morality. Rather, religion, philosophy, and whatever else should act as guides for people doing the right thing.

The Economy

Regarding economic policy, the Libertarian Party calls for extreme reduction in government intervention. This necessitates the lowering of taxes, decreasing the national debt, allowing people to opt out of Social Security, and possibly even abolishing the IRS. Parallel with this vision is the elimination of the welfare state.

Most surface level criticism of Libertarians focuses on the welfare repercussions of these policies. Under a purely libertarian leadership, less or no money would be given to projects like Medicare and Medicaid or to public schools and art initiatives or to anything attempting to help the poor or disabled. Libertarians are not heartless, though, and they recognize that not everyone can take care of themselves. For this reason, Libertarianism calls for private charity and for church organizations to take up the slack of government, watching out for the disenfranchised (and probably more efficiently).

Their Ideology

Libertarians are bound by their sense of fairness, and for them, fairness is everyone being granted perfect freedom. Philosophically, this aligns Libertarianism with classical liberal thought, in contrast to Democrats’ liberalism and progressivism and Republicans’ conservatism. Libertarians convictions are not tied directly to something being novel or traditional but rather to whatever grants people the most freedom.

Economically, there is lots of support for this way of thinking, the idea that governments are inefficient and that the free-market can best support society. Socially, Libertarians stand by the hard-to-argue-with concept of freedom and, as the name would imply, liberty. Libertarians may think drugs are bad or guns are dangerous, but ultimately they want that decision to be up to every individual for them to choose freely.

Section Break

As I said a few weeks ago, there’s a lot about Libertarians that I like. It’s hard to contest the practicality or efficiency of their policies (if properly enacted), and most of the time, I think their advocacy of freedom is a good thing—in some ways as God intended.

But there’s still plenty that needs to be critiqued: drawing a line for what constitutes harming another individual can be tricky if not impossible; there has been significant scholarly disagreement on the tenability of a free-market health care program; the question still stands whether people really can manage their own best interest. Freedom can never be the ultimate goal. Freedom is simply a virtue and a tool in accomplishing the ultimate goal. And like any tool, it should be discarded when it is no longer useful.

So what does it take to be a good Libertarian? As with members of the other major parties, the first requirement is not looking down on those with different ideas; it’s understanding those positions and learning to sympathize with them; it’s not thinking your position is the only “logical” one. Libertarians should continue to advocate from their minority position for practical and efficient change, the sort of change that will ultimately increase the well-being of millions. But in advocating for that change, they cannot lose sight of the outliers and the collateral; they must continue to care for all, even if those individuals don’t fit into their algorithm. This means sometimes that freedom can’t be the only criteria when enacting social policy or shaping the government’s hand in the economy. This means remembering there are things that matter more.


Add yours →

  1. I’m glad you decided to include this shorter post about America’s third-largest party. I have read your posts in this series, and unsurprisingly to myself, I am again joyful that I consider myself to more closely align with Libertarian ideologies. I believe that Libertarianism, generally speaking, is more in-line with what God intended for governments to be, as you briefly proposed.

    That being send, I like what you said about a short-coming of true Libertarianism. That is, there are times when the government SHOULD be involved. I’m not sure if the party has defined what areas they believe the government should step in. I know it goes against their primary ideology, but I think it is good for Libertarianism to make a list of healthy government involvement. Because they have not make such a list, I believe it leaves a bad taste in people’s mouths because people might incorrectly view Libertarianism to be too close to anarchism. Libertarianism occasionally comes across as semi-anarchist, very unfortunately.

    You said, “The question still stands whether people really can manage their own best interest.” While that is true, another question is also worth asking: “The question still stands whether the government really can manage their people’s best interest.” As I typed that, I thought about a bunch of selected oligarchs imposing their options on others. I would much rather ask the later question than the former. In other words, personally, I put much more faith in individual people and their own upbringing… than I trust a select number of powerful people who tell others what is best for everyone.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Good closing paragraphs that summarize the main issues. There is a lot I like about libertarians. I feel that their drive for total freedom has good intentions. My biggest fear with an immediate implementation of this system, as you mentioned, would be the missing government programs. If you jumped straight from public schools to a solely private system many families would rather just keep their money and not send their kids to school. I trust that libertarians would see this issue and create a more smooth transition for all government programs to private ones. See if the demand remains after the public have been exposed to the product.
    Also, governments should be able to restrict corporate monopolies in order to protect people from being taken advantage of. Or else we will be paying inflated costs for basic needs.
    Socially/Morally, I disagree with allowing people to create their own moral code of law. (Yes, I support theological authoritarianism.)

    All this is vain as state rights are being ruined by federal court rulings that are outside their constitutional rights. States are meant to be a way for people with different ideologies to have a place where they can live in peace while the folks next door do what makes them happy. Instead, federal courts feel it is their job to slap their rules on everyone.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: